CHARITY VERSUS DEVELOPMENT





“True compassion is more than flinging a coin to a beggar. It comes to see that an edifice which produces beggars needs restructuring.”
-Reverend Martin Luther King, 1967 [1]  http://www.globalresearch.ca/charity-versus-solidarity-do-development-ngos-do-more-harm-than-good/5343236
Charity can be defined as giving to help make people’s lives better while community development is moving beyond charity to walk together and help improve people’s lives. Today, lots of people prefer to do charity than being committed in partnering to improve people's standard of living.  Community development does not only improve the lives of others around us but also helps to improve ours as partners. https://attackpoverty.org/2011/charity-vs-development/
The following table according to Cooperative Baptist Fellowship best describe the differences between charity and community development.

Charity
Community Development
Meet a need
Empower people
Doing 'for'
Doing 'with'
What you think they need
What they say they want
Arrogance
Cooperation
Over/under
Equal
Not necessarily personal relationships
Personal relationships
Individuals/families
Systems
Short-term
Long-term
Single event
Change
Immediate fix
Long-term
Network
Net-weave
Doing justice
Doing reconciliation
Mercy for one
Mercy for masses
Dependence
Self-worth
Easy success
High risk of failure
Pities people
Respects people
Projects
Process
Develops dependence
Develops interdependence
Tell them
Ask them


This table is a proof that the best we can offer is initiating developmental efforts than just pitying persons and throwing down leftovers on them.  
You can visit us at theruralpeople.blogspot.com and on twitter.com/theruralpeople .  Also send your email to theruralpeople@gmail.com and share your comments.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

LOCAL MINING AND THE ENVIRONMENT

Image
The enormous task of fighting poverty and earning a source of livelihood has driven many rural dwellers into local mining.   The process of local mining is one whereby precious stones and other mineral deposits are brought/dugged out by untrained rural dwellers.   This method of mining does not take cognisance of all the safety measures that are needed to be in place for such vocation and also does not recognise the negative environmental hazards that this will cause the rural populace. Although this industry has the potential of reducing poverty through income and employment generation, the use of primitive methods of mining constantly contributes its toll to the degradation of our environment. http://www.ajol.info/index.php/jorind/article/view/42333 Regrettably, while the government spends lots of money on importing these precious stones and mineral deposits, lots of these rural dwellers can be trained and equipped in harnessing this profession as they have chosen it so that o
Read more

THE NEED FOR THEMATIC INVESTIGATION/RESEARCH IN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES

THE NEED FOR THEMATIC INVESTIGATION/RESEARCH IN COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ACTIVITIES The need for research cannot be overemphasized in the organization of community development activities.    A lot of persons have depended on common sense in selecting what they consider as the most common need of the rural dwellers and have ignorantly embarked on such activities.   Thematic investigation is always one of the first activities embarked upon before and after a community development proposal has been approved.   Again, thematic investigation also   means ‘searching for facts; finding answers to questions;   identifying an existing problem and   getting closest solutions to these identified problem’ amongst others. Again, thematic investigation gives the rural dwellers the opportunity to explain in their own words how they feel, what they think and how they make sense of the world they live in.     The following are some of the reasons why we embark on thematic investigation/
Read more